Assignment 2 Discussion

Support Files

For those it might be useful for, I've created a Makefile and a Visual Studio 2005 project for lz-kdtree you can find here. The Makefile will build, and the VS 2005 solution will build Release/lz-kdtree.dll and Debug/lz-kdtree_d.dll. I find this kind of setup useful if you want to keep lz-kdtree.cpp in a "local" directory outside the pbrt source tree (e.g., in a cvs repository without the rest of the pbrt source). Note that you'll have to add your own copy of lz-kdtree to the Source Files in the VS solution file, and you'll have to change the path in the Makefile on line 10 to point to your own copy of pbrt.


Q.1 Default Killeroo Scene (DougJohnston)

Using the scenes includes in the zip file, I get the following statistics:

    Total shapes created                                    532.2k
    Triangle Ray Intersections                              673.8k:4826.8k (13.96%)
    Triangles created                                       532.2k
Kd-Tree Accelerator
    Avg. number of primitives in leaf nodes                 3.965M:1.376M (2.88x)
    Interior kd-tree nodes made                             1.376M
    Leaf kd-tree nodes made                                 1.376M
    Maximum number of primitives in leaf node               284

which is significantly different from those in the project description.


The scene in the zip file has one more level of subdivisions for the killeroo models. That's why the numbers of tree nodes and triangle ray intersections are much higher than the numbers given in the example.

Q.2 Problems with const (LeeHendrickson)

I'm having some issues with dynamically creating new nodes in my lazy kd-tree. The crux of the issue is that both Intersect and IntersectP must be const methods (as they implement pure virtual methods from Primitive which are themselves const); however, in lazy evaluation these are also exactly the methods in which changes do need to be made to the kd-tree (at the very least either 1.) more nodes will need to be allocated, or 2.) nodes already allocated will need to have initLeaf or initInteriorNode called on them, neither of which is a const operation). Hopefully I'm missing something simple, any pointers/hints would be appreciated. (please don't tell me the answer is to make everything mutable...)


Well, what I ended up doing was just going the mutable route, moving as much as I could into a mutable member structure, and setting the building functions const so as to be able to be called from Intersect (even though some variables such as the number of free and alloc'ed nodes need to stay in the tree itself). The problem with const_cast'ing is having to do it on the this pointer that must also be const for all functions called from intersect, which just feels more kludgy. By using mutable members the functions themselves can stay in the top level tree and stay const. Quick and dirty, but given the framework of pbrt I don't see any good way around it. Any better suggestions are welcome. (LeeHendrickson)

Q.3 Performance Profiling (LeeHendrickson)

Anybody have a good way of profiling pbrt on the Myths? The problem is that gprof doesn't handle profiling across shared libraries (even when compiled with -pg) and converting pbrt to use static libraries would be a pain and counter-productive. Normally I would use sprof but it's unfortunately absent on the Myths.


Q.4 Debugging with GDB (YiLangMok)

I remember somewhere (can't find it) that stated that GDB 6+ should be able to debug the .so plugins, but I haven't managed to get this to work. At best, I can get the stack trace, but not the line number that segfaults occur on. Are there any flags I need to set in the Makefile to enable this?